•  First Team All-State Pirates
     
    Dan Molcha (1949)
    Pete Uremovich (1962)
    Al Schmidt (1964)
    Bill Schmidt (1965)
    George Uremovich (1969)
    Kirk Kuzmiz, Walt Prochino (1971)
    Ken Dike, Bob Uremovich (1973)
    Tom Vandenburgh (1975)
    Kelly Keough, Randy Shuman, Tom Szmagaj (1976)
    Mike Chelovich (1977)
    Max Gill, Tom Jelesky, Larry Tharp (1978)
    Greg Mackey (1980)
    Scott Plesha (1981)
    John Ogiego (1982)
    Chris Cochran, Tim O'Shea (1985)
    Mike Mackey, Brian Storey (1986)
    Todd Gill, Tim Seneff, Tom Szmagaj (1987)
    Mike Parker (1988)
    Doug Downs (1990)
    Donnie Bankhead, Joe Clark (1991)
    Dave Joseforsky, Jamel Williams, Zac Wells (1992)
    Warren Connor, Kevin Erny (1994)
    Matt Sieker (1995
    Joe Giordano, Montell Pace (1996)
    Ryan Francis, Aaron Steele (1997)
    Eugene Wilson, Mike Megyesi (1998)
    Adam Fedak (1999)
    Riley Larimore (2001
    Timidayo McCarthy (2002)
    Brandon Mosely (2003)
    Michael Neal (2004)
    James Aldridge, Brandon Jordan, Dexter Larimore (2005
    Demario Richardson, Jarret Rucker, Roosevelt Williams (2007)
    Keith Dockery, Aaron Kaczmarski (2008)
    James Travis (2009)